Publication Ethics and Malpractice Statement

Publication Ethics and Malpractice Statement

Journal of Science and Science Education (JoSSEd)

Journal of Science and Science Education (JoSSEd) is an international, peer-reviewed, open-access scholarly journal published by the Postgraduate Program, University of Mataram, Indonesia. The journal is committed to maintaining the highest standards of publication ethics, academic integrity, editorial independence, and transparency throughout the scholarly publishing process.

This Publication Ethics and Malpractice Statement establishes the ethical responsibilities of authors, editors, reviewers, and the publisher. The policy is informed by the principles and recommendations of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) and internationally recognized standards of responsible research and scholarly communication.

JoSSEd does not tolerate plagiarism, self-plagiarism, data fabrication, data falsification, inappropriate authorship, duplicate publication, manipulation of peer review, or any other form of research and publication misconduct.

1. Ethical Responsibilities of Editors

1.1 Editorial Independence and Decision-Making

Editors are responsible for making fair, independent, and evidence-based decisions regarding the acceptance or rejection of manuscripts. Editorial decisions must be based on scientific originality, methodological quality, relevance to the journal's focus and scope, clarity of presentation, ethical compliance, and the contribution of the research to existing knowledge.

Decisions must not be influenced by authors' nationality, ethnicity, gender, religion, political beliefs, institutional affiliation, personal relationships, or financial considerations. The publisher and other parties must not interfere with independent editorial judgments.

1.2 Confidentiality

Editors and editorial staff must maintain the confidentiality of submitted manuscripts, reviewer identities where protected by the review model, editorial correspondence, and unpublished research data. Manuscript information must not be disclosed to unauthorized individuals or used for personal research or professional advantage.

1.3 Conflicts of Interest

Editors must disclose any actual, potential, or perceived conflicts of interest that could compromise their impartiality. Editors with relevant conflicts must withdraw from handling the manuscript and transfer editorial responsibility to another qualified editor.

1.4 Fair Evaluation

Editors must ensure that manuscripts are evaluated objectively, consistently, and without discrimination. Editorial assessments should consider the scientific merits of each manuscript and the recommendations of qualified peer reviewers.

1.5 Handling Ethical Complaints

Editors are responsible for investigating credible allegations of research or publication misconduct, including complaints received before or after publication. Investigations must be conducted fairly, confidentially where appropriate, and with opportunities for the relevant parties to provide explanations and supporting evidence.

2. Ethical Responsibilities of Reviewers

2.1 Contribution to Editorial Decisions

Peer reviewers assist editors in evaluating the scientific quality, originality, validity, and relevance of submitted manuscripts. Review reports should provide constructive, specific, evidence-based, and professionally expressed comments that help editors make informed decisions and assist authors in improving their manuscripts.

2.2 Objectivity and Professional Conduct

Reviewers must evaluate manuscripts objectively and avoid personal criticism, discriminatory remarks, hostile language, or unsupported allegations. Scientific disagreements must be explained clearly and supported by appropriate reasoning or evidence.

2.3 Confidentiality

All manuscripts received for review must be treated as confidential documents. Reviewers must not share manuscripts, disclose unpublished findings, distribute research materials, or discuss manuscript contents with unauthorized parties without editorial permission.

2.4 Competence and Timeliness

Reviewers should accept assignments only when they possess sufficient expertise to evaluate the manuscript and can reasonably complete the review within the requested period. Reviewers who are unable to provide a timely or competent assessment must promptly inform the editor.

2.5 Disclosure of Conflicts of Interest

Reviewers must disclose any personal, financial, professional, academic, or institutional relationships that may affect their impartiality. Reviewers must decline assignments when such conflicts could compromise an independent assessment.

2.6 Identification of Ethical Concerns

Reviewers should notify the editor of suspected plagiarism, substantial similarity with previously published work, duplicate publication, questionable data presentation, inappropriate citations, or other potential ethical concerns identified during the review process.

3. Ethical Responsibilities of Authors

3.1 Originality and Scientific Integrity

Authors must submit original scholarly work that represents an accurate and honest account of the research conducted. Manuscripts must be free from plagiarism, inappropriate text recycling, fabricated or falsified data, misleading presentation of findings, and other forms of scientific misconduct.

3.2 Accuracy and Reproducibility

Authors must present research objectives, methodologies, data analysis procedures, findings, and conclusions accurately and transparently. Sufficient methodological information should be provided to enable critical evaluation and, where appropriate, reproducibility of the research.

3.3 Multiple, Redundant, and Concurrent Publication

Authors must not submit substantially the same manuscript to more than one journal simultaneously. Manuscripts previously published in another scholarly outlet are generally not eligible for publication in JoSSEd, except where a legitimate form of secondary publication is expressly permitted under applicable editorial policies and transparently disclosed.

3.4 Acknowledgement of Sources

Authors must properly acknowledge the work and intellectual contributions of others. All borrowed ideas, data, methods, figures, and textual materials must be appropriately cited. References must accurately represent the sources consulted and must not be fabricated or manipulated.

3.5 Authorship and Contributions

Authorship must be limited to individuals who have made substantial scholarly contributions to the research and manuscript, participated in drafting or critically revising the work, approved the final version, and accepted appropriate accountability for its integrity.

Guest authorship, gift authorship, ghost authorship, and the inappropriate exclusion of legitimate contributors are prohibited. Authors must provide a transparent contribution statement, preferably following the CRediT taxonomy.

3.6 Changes in Authorship

Requests to add, remove, or rearrange authors after submission must be supported by a clear justification and written agreement from all affected authors. Such changes require editorial approval. Requests made after acceptance or publication may require additional documentation and formal editorial consideration.

3.7 Funding and Conflicts of Interest

Authors must disclose all relevant funding sources, grant numbers, and financial or non-financial conflicts of interest that could reasonably influence the research or its interpretation. The role of funding organizations in the research process must be stated where applicable.

3.8 Correction of Significant Errors

When authors discover significant errors or inaccuracies in their submitted or published work, they must promptly notify the editorial office and cooperate in correcting the scholarly record through an appropriate editorial action.

4. Plagiarism and Similarity Screening

JoSSEd requires all submitted manuscripts to demonstrate originality and appropriate scholarly attribution. Manuscripts may undergo similarity screening using appropriate plagiarism-detection software as part of the editorial evaluation process.

Plagiarism includes presenting another person's words, ideas, data, figures, or intellectual contributions as one's own without proper acknowledgement. Self-plagiarism or inappropriate text recycling may occur when authors reuse substantial portions of their previously published work without adequate disclosure or citation.

Similarity reports are evaluated contextually. Editors consider the nature, location, and significance of overlapping material rather than relying exclusively on a numerical similarity score. Legitimate quotations, references, standard methodological terminology, and properly acknowledged materials are assessed appropriately.

Manuscripts containing substantial unattributed overlap or other evidence of plagiarism may be rejected. Allegations identified after publication may result in corrections, expressions of concern, retractions, or other appropriate actions following an editorial investigation.

5. Research Ethics and Human or Animal Participants

Research involving human participants, including students, teachers, patients, or other individuals, must comply with applicable ethical principles, institutional requirements, and relevant national regulations.

Where required, authors must obtain approval from an appropriate research ethics committee before conducting the study. The manuscript should identify the approving committee and approval reference number, where applicable.

Informed consent must be obtained where required. Research involving children or other vulnerable participants must include appropriate safeguards, including parental or guardian consent and participant assent when applicable.

Authors must protect participant privacy, confidentiality, and personal data. Identifiable information must not be disclosed without appropriate authorization.

Research involving animals must comply with applicable animal welfare standards and institutional or national regulations. Authors should provide information on relevant ethical approval and measures taken to minimize animal suffering.

6. Data Integrity, Transparency, and Availability

Authors are responsible for the accuracy, authenticity, and integrity of research data. Data fabrication, falsification, selective manipulation, inappropriate image alteration, and misleading statistical reporting are strictly prohibited.

Authors should retain research data and supporting documentation for a reasonable period in accordance with applicable institutional requirements, legal obligations, and disciplinary standards.

Where appropriate, authors are encouraged to make supporting data, research instruments, analytical procedures, or supplementary materials available to facilitate verification and reproducibility. Data sharing must respect participant confidentiality, intellectual property rights, and relevant legal or ethical restrictions.

The journal may request supporting data or documentation when necessary to investigate concerns about research integrity.

7. Use of Artificial Intelligence in Scholarly Publishing

JoSSEd recognizes that artificial intelligence (AI) and AI-assisted technologies may support certain aspects of research and manuscript preparation. However, their use must be responsible, transparent, and consistent with academic integrity.

7.1 Responsibilities of Authors

Authors remain fully responsible for the accuracy, originality, validity, and integrity of all manuscript content, including material developed with AI assistance. AI tools must not be listed as authors because they cannot assume responsibility or accountability for scholarly work.

7.2 Disclosure of AI Use

Authors must disclose substantive use of generative AI tools in manuscript preparation, including the tool used, the purpose of its use, and the relevant stage of manuscript development. Routine spelling and grammar assistance that does not materially generate or alter scholarly content may be treated differently under the journal's applicable AI disclosure requirements.

7.3 Prohibited AI Practices

AI tools must not be used to fabricate research data, generate fictitious references, manipulate scientific results, misrepresent research methods, or conceal plagiarism. Authors must independently verify AI-assisted content and ensure that its use does not infringe intellectual property or confidentiality obligations.

7.4 AI Use by Editors and Reviewers

Editors and reviewers must protect manuscript confidentiality and must not upload unpublished manuscripts, confidential peer-review materials, or sensitive research data into external AI systems without appropriate authorization and adequate confidentiality safeguards. Editorial decisions and peer-review judgments remain the responsibility of qualified human experts.

8. Peer Review Integrity

JoSSEd is committed to a fair, transparent, independent, and rigorous peer-review process. Manuscripts are initially screened by editors and, when suitable, evaluated by qualified reviewers with relevant subject expertise.

The journal prohibits fabricated reviewer identities, manipulated reviewer recommendations, undisclosed conflicts of interest, coercive citation practices, and attempts to improperly influence editorial decisions.

Editors must ensure that reviewer selection is based on relevant expertise, independence, and the ability to provide a fair assessment. The confidentiality requirements of the journal's adopted peer-review model must be respected.

Editorial decisions are based on the scientific merit of the manuscript, reviewers' evaluations, ethical compliance, and the journal's publication standards. Acceptance is never guaranteed by submission, payment, personal relationships, or institutional affiliation.

9. Allegations of Research and Publication Misconduct

JoSSEd takes all credible allegations of research or publication misconduct seriously, whether they concern submitted manuscripts or published articles. Allegations may involve plagiarism, data fabrication, falsification, authorship disputes, unethical research practices, peer-review manipulation, undisclosed conflicts of interest, or other violations of publication ethics.

The editorial office will assess allegations according to their seriousness and the available evidence. When appropriate, the journal may request explanations, supporting documentation, or original research data from the authors and may consult reviewers, institutions, or other relevant parties.

Individuals involved in an investigation must be treated fairly and given a reasonable opportunity to respond. Investigations should respect confidentiality and due process while protecting the integrity of the scholarly record.

Depending on the findings, editorial actions may include requesting clarification, rejecting a manuscript, publishing a correction, issuing an expression of concern, retracting an article, or notifying the relevant institution or other responsible body.

10. Corrections, Retractions, and Expressions of Concern

10.1 Corrections

A correction may be issued when a published article contains an error that requires amendment but does not fundamentally invalidate the main findings or conclusions. Corrections must clearly identify the original article and describe the information being corrected.

10.2 Retractions

An article may be retracted when there is reliable evidence that its findings are substantially unreliable, when serious research misconduct has occurred, when publication constitutes substantial plagiarism or redundant publication, or when serious ethical violations invalidate the publication.

Retraction notices should clearly explain the reasons for the retraction and remain permanently linked to the original article. Retracted articles should remain identifiable as part of the scholarly record rather than being silently removed, except in exceptional circumstances requiring content removal.

10.3 Expressions of Concern

An expression of concern may be issued when serious questions arise regarding the integrity or reliability of a published article but the available evidence is inconclusive or an investigation remains unresolved.

10.4 Article Removal

Complete removal of published content is considered only in exceptional circumstances, such as significant legal risks, serious privacy violations, or content that poses a substantial risk of harm. Where feasible, bibliographic information and an explanatory notice will be retained.

11. Complaints and Appeals

Authors and other stakeholders may submit complaints or appeals concerning editorial procedures, peer-review conduct, publication ethics, or editorial decisions through the journal's official communication channels.

Appeals must include a clear explanation and relevant supporting evidence. An appeal does not automatically result in reconsideration or acceptance of a manuscript.

Where practicable, complaints and appeals should be reviewed by an editor who was not directly responsible for the disputed decision. The journal will seek to resolve concerns fairly, objectively, and in accordance with applicable editorial policies.

12. Copyright and Intellectual Property

Authors must ensure that their manuscripts do not infringe the intellectual property rights of others. Permission must be obtained where required for the reproduction or adaptation of copyrighted figures, tables, illustrations, or other materials.

The copyright ownership and licensing conditions applicable to published articles are governed by the journal's official Copyright and Licensing Policy. Authors are responsible for reviewing and complying with those conditions before publication.

13. Responsibilities of the Publisher

The Postgraduate Program, University of Mataram, as the publisher of JoSSEd, supports editorial independence, ethical scholarly communication, transparency, and responsible journal management.

The publisher works with the editorial team to maintain appropriate procedures for handling ethical concerns, safeguarding the scholarly record, supporting corrections and retractions when necessary, and ensuring that publication decisions are not improperly influenced by commercial, institutional, or personal interests.

14. Ethical Oversight and Policy Updates

JoSSEd is committed to continuous improvement of its publication ethics policies and editorial practices. The journal may periodically review and update these policies to reflect developments in scholarly publishing, research integrity, and internationally recognized ethical guidance.

All authors, reviewers, editors, and other stakeholders are expected to comply with the policies in effect during the relevant stage of manuscript submission, review, and publication.

International Publication Ethics References

The journal's ethical framework is informed by recognized principles and guidance from the following organizations:

Journal of Science and Science Education (JoSSEd)
Published by the Postgraduate Program, University of Mataram, Indonesia.
Website: https://jppipa.unram.ac.id/index.php/jossed