Screening for Plagiarism

Plagiarism Policy

Journal of Science and Science Education (JoSSEd)

Journal of Science and Science Education (JoSSEd) is committed to maintaining high standards of academic integrity, originality, transparency, and ethical scholarly publishing. The journal strictly prohibits plagiarism, inappropriate self-plagiarism, redundant publication, and other forms of academic misconduct.

To safeguard the originality of published research, all manuscripts submitted to JoSSEd are screened using Turnitin before entering the external peer-review process. The journal establishes a maximum similarity index of 20% as a mandatory requirement for manuscript consideration.

Mandatory Similarity Requirement

The maximum permitted Turnitin similarity index is 20%. Manuscripts with a similarity index exceeding 20% will be rejected during the initial editorial screening and will not proceed to peer review. This requirement applies to all submitted manuscripts without exception to the numerical threshold.

1. Definition of Plagiarism

Plagiarism is the use or presentation of another person's words, ideas, research findings, data, methods, figures, illustrations, or intellectual contributions as one's own without proper acknowledgement or citation.

Plagiarism is considered a serious violation of academic integrity, whether committed intentionally or unintentionally. Authors are fully responsible for ensuring that their manuscripts are original and that all sources are appropriately acknowledged.

2. Forms of Plagiarism

JoSSEd recognizes the following forms of plagiarism and related academic misconduct:

  1. Direct Plagiarism: Reproducing another author's text without appropriate quotation or citation.
  2. Paraphrasing Plagiarism: Presenting another author's ideas or findings in modified wording without acknowledging the original source.
  3. Self-Plagiarism: Reusing substantial portions of previously published work without appropriate citation or transparent disclosure.
  4. Mosaic Plagiarism: Combining copied phrases or passages from different sources without proper attribution.
  5. Data and Figure Plagiarism: Using another researcher's data, figures, tables, images, or research materials without appropriate acknowledgement or permission.
  6. Idea Plagiarism: Presenting another person's original theories, concepts, or research contributions as one's own.
  7. Source Misrepresentation: Using inaccurate, misleading, or fabricated citations to conceal the original source of scholarly content.
  8. AI-Assisted Plagiarism: Using artificial intelligence tools to reproduce, disguise, or present unattributed material from existing sources as original scholarly work.

3. Plagiarism Detection Using Turnitin

JoSSEd uses Turnitin as its official similarity detection software to examine submitted manuscripts for textual overlap with existing scholarly publications, online sources, institutional repositories, and other materials indexed by the software.

Every submitted manuscript undergoes Turnitin screening as part of the initial editorial assessment. The similarity report is examined by the editorial team to determine compliance with the journal's maximum similarity threshold and to identify potential plagiarism.

The Turnitin similarity index serves as a mandatory administrative screening criterion. However, similarity scores do not independently establish whether plagiarism has occurred. Editors also evaluate the nature, extent, sources, and context of matched materials when assessing research integrity.

4. Maximum Similarity Threshold and Rejection Policy

JoSSEd applies a strict maximum overall similarity index of 20% to all manuscripts submitted for publication consideration.

Manuscripts with similarity scores of 20% or below may proceed to further editorial evaluation, provided that no plagiarism or other ethical violations are identified. Manuscripts with similarity scores above 20% are rejected at the initial screening stage.

Turnitin Similarity Screening Result Editorial Decision
0%–20% Meets Similarity Requirement Eligible for further editorial evaluation and peer review, subject to compliance with all other journal requirements.
Above 20% Does Not Meet Requirement Rejected (Desk Rejection). The manuscript will not proceed to the peer-review stage.
Any Similarity Score Evidence of Plagiarism The manuscript may be rejected when plagiarism or serious research integrity violations are identified, regardless of its overall similarity percentage.

Manuscripts exceeding the 20% similarity threshold are not eligible for revision within the same submission process. Authors who wish to submit an improved manuscript must prepare a new submission that satisfies the journal's originality and editorial requirements.

5. Similarity Report Evaluation

The editorial team evaluates Turnitin similarity reports to identify textual overlap and assess whether the manuscript complies with the journal's originality standards.

To ensure consistent screening, the journal applies its established Turnitin settings and evaluates the resulting similarity index. Bibliographic references, properly quoted material, and standard scientific terminology may be considered in accordance with the journal's similarity screening procedures.

Editors also examine whether matched passages contain unattributed copying, inappropriate paraphrasing, excessive text recycling, or other forms of academic misconduct.

The maximum 20% threshold remains mandatory. Proper citation does not automatically exempt a manuscript from the journal's similarity limit, and a low similarity score does not guarantee freedom from plagiarism.

6. Initial Screening and Editorial Procedure

The plagiarism screening process is conducted according to the following procedures:

  1. Manuscript Submission: Authors submit their manuscripts through the journal's Online Journal System (OJS).
  2. Initial Editorial Assessment: The editorial team checks the manuscript's completeness, relevance, formatting, and compliance with submission requirements.
  3. Turnitin Screening: The submitted manuscript is examined using Turnitin to determine its overall similarity index.
  4. Similarity Verification: The editorial team evaluates the similarity report and determines whether the manuscript meets the maximum 20% threshold.
  5. Automatic Editorial Rejection: Manuscripts with a similarity index above 20% are rejected during initial editorial screening and are not forwarded to reviewers.
  6. Further Editorial Evaluation: Manuscripts with a similarity index of 20% or below may proceed to further editorial assessment, provided that no plagiarism or other ethical violations are identified.
  7. Single-Blind Peer Review: Eligible manuscripts proceed to the journal's single-blind peer-review process.

7. Rejection of Manuscripts Exceeding 20% Similarity

Manuscripts with a Turnitin similarity index exceeding 20% are considered non-compliant with JoSSEd's mandatory originality screening requirement and will be rejected without proceeding to external peer review.

The editorial office will communicate the rejection decision to the corresponding author through the journal's official submission system.

A manuscript rejected for exceeding the similarity threshold cannot continue through the review process under the same submission. Authors may submit a substantially improved version as a new manuscript, provided that it satisfies all applicable editorial and ethical requirements.

Rejection based on a similarity score above 20% is an editorial screening decision and does not, by itself, constitute a formal finding of plagiarism.

8. Self-Plagiarism and Redundant Publication

JoSSEd prohibits inappropriate self-plagiarism, redundant publication, and undisclosed substantial reuse of previously published materials.

Authors must appropriately cite their previous publications and transparently disclose any substantial overlap between the submitted manuscript and previously published or disseminated research.

Manuscripts must demonstrate a meaningful original scholarly contribution and must not substantially duplicate existing publications.

The journal does not accept simultaneous submission of substantially the same manuscript to multiple scholarly journals.

9. Responsibilities of Authors

Authors are responsible for ensuring that submitted manuscripts meet the journal's originality and similarity requirements before submission.

Authors must:

  • Submit original scholarly work that has not been published elsewhere in substantially the same form.
  • Ensure that the manuscript's similarity index does not exceed 20%.
  • Provide appropriate citations and acknowledgements for all borrowed ideas, data, and materials.
  • Avoid direct copying, inappropriate paraphrasing, and excessive text recycling.
  • Obtain necessary permissions for copyrighted materials.
  • Disclose relevant prior publications or overlapping research.
  • Ensure that AI-assisted content complies with the journal's academic integrity requirements.
  • Accept the editorial consequences of failing to meet the journal's mandatory similarity threshold.

10. Responsibilities of Editors and Reviewers

Editors are responsible for ensuring that all manuscripts undergo Turnitin similarity screening before external peer review and that the maximum similarity threshold is applied consistently.

The editorial team must reject manuscripts exceeding the 20% threshold and maintain appropriate documentation of screening outcomes and editorial decisions.

Reviewers are expected to identify and report suspected plagiarism, substantial textual overlap, inappropriate citation practices, or other originality concerns that may not have been detected during initial screening.

All plagiarism-related concerns must be handled objectively, confidentially, and in accordance with the journal's Publication Ethics Policy.

11. Plagiarism Identified During or After Peer Review

If potential plagiarism is identified during peer review, the handling editor may suspend the evaluation process and investigate the concern. Manuscripts found to contain serious plagiarism or other research integrity violations may be rejected regardless of their initial similarity score.

If a revised manuscript is rescreened and its similarity index exceeds 20%, the manuscript will be rejected in accordance with the journal's mandatory similarity requirement.

If plagiarism is identified after acceptance but before publication, the journal may suspend publication and withdraw the acceptance decision following appropriate editorial assessment.

If plagiarism is discovered after publication, the editorial team may issue a correction, expression of concern, or retraction, depending on the nature and severity of the violation.

12. Publication Ethics and Misconduct Investigation

JoSSEd handles allegations of plagiarism and research misconduct in accordance with its Publication Ethics Policy and the principles recommended by the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE).

When credible allegations arise, the editorial team may examine similarity reports, original sources, supporting documentation, and explanations provided by the authors.

Editorial decisions are based on the available evidence and the seriousness of the identified concerns. Where appropriate, authors will be given an opportunity to respond to allegations of misconduct.

The journal may reject a manuscript, withdraw acceptance, publish a correction, issue an expression of concern, retract an article, or notify the relevant institution when justified by the findings.

13. Plagiarism Screening Flow

Manuscript Submission

↓

Initial Editorial Screening

↓

Turnitin Similarity Screening

↓

Similarity Index Evaluation
Maximum Permitted Similarity: 20%

↓

Similarity ≤ 20%
Eligible for Further Editorial Evaluation

↓

Single-Blind Peer Review
Similarity > 20%
REJECTED - DESK REJECTION
The manuscript will not proceed to peer review.

Official Plagiarism Screening Statement

All manuscripts submitted to the Journal of Science and Science Education (JoSSEd) must undergo plagiarism and similarity screening using Turnitin. The journal applies a strict maximum similarity index of 20%. Any manuscript with a similarity index exceeding 20% will be rejected during the initial editorial screening and will not proceed to peer review. Manuscripts with similarity scores of 20% or below remain subject to further evaluation for plagiarism, originality, scientific quality, and compliance with publication ethics.

Journal of Science and Science Education (JoSSEd)
Published by the Postgraduate Program, University of Mataram, Indonesia.
Website: https://jppipa.unram.ac.id/index.php/jossed